6 Best Affordable Drugstore Eyeshadow Palettes
This post contains affiliate links. View my full disclosure policy for more information.
Finding the best drugstore eyeshadow palette can be a total game-changer for your eye makeup routine. Whether you’re into neutral shades, bold colors, or shimmer finishes, there’s a drugstore palette out there that can rival even the most high-end luxury brands—and all without the hefty price tag.
This list features six major wins for your makeup bag, offering incredible color payoff, long-lasting wear, and everything you need to create a variety of eyeshadow looks, from natural and everyday to smokey and dramatic. The good news? These palettes are affordable, compact, and perfect for achieving everything from natural looks to a full beat.
6 Best Drugstore Eyeshadow Palettes
Wet ‘n Wild Always Naked Palette
If you’ve been searching for the perfect nude eyeshadow palette, look no further. The Wet ‘n Wild Always Naked Palette offers 16 versatile shades, including a mix of shimmers, mattes, and even a full glitter shade.
This neutral tones palette is a great way to build everything from soft natural looks to dramatic smokey eyes. The smooth formula is super blendable and easy to work with, making it ideal for beginners and pros alike.
Plus, it’s a drugstore version that channels the vibes of the iconic Urban Decay Naked Palette—but at a great price.
Wet ‘n Wild Color Icon 10-Pan Eyeshadow Palette
For a more compact option, the Color Icon 10-Pan Eyeshadow Palette by Wet ‘n Wild is a fantastic pick. This palette offers different shades and color stories, so you can choose one that matches your mood. (My personal favorite is the “Nude Awakening” palette.)
With a mix of matte shades and shimmer shades, it’s perfect for creating cohesive eyeshadow looks. It’s also incredibly affordable, making it one of the most popular drugstore choices.
Whether you’re going for warm-toned shades or something cooler, this palette delivers amazing quality for an unbeatable price.
e.l.f. Perfect 10 Eyeshadow Palette
The e.l.f. Perfect 10 Eyeshadow Palette combines easy application with convenience. Its slim packaging is ideal for travel, and the wide range of different finishes makes it suitable for any occasion.
From neutral shades to pops of colors, this palette has everything you need to create natural looks, special occasion glam, or a sultry smokey eye. I’ve really enjoyed the cooler tones in the “Everyday Smoky” palette. You can definitely make that one work for everyday looks or glam it up a little!
The formula is smooth and blendable, making it another good reason to add this to your cart ASAP.
e.l.f. Bite-Size Eyeshadow Palette
The e.l.f. Bite-Size Eyeshadow Palette is all about simplicity and efficiency. These tiny, 4-pan palettes come in various color stories and finishes, making them a great choice for minimalists or anyone who likes to keep their makeup bag clutter-free.
Despite their small size, these palettes pack a punch with their rich color payoff and long-lasting wear. (Seriously, the formula on these are amazing!) Whether you’re after warm neutrals or bold, bright colors, these palettes are perfect for quick, on-the-go eyeshadow looks.
My favorite ones are Cream & Sugar, I Love You A Latte (all mattes), and Truffles.
ColourPop 9-Pan Eyeshadow Palette
For beauty lovers, the ColourPop 9-Pan Eyeshadow Palette is a holy grail. This palette delivers the best quality eyeshadow for the price (they feel SO high end!), with smooth formulas and incredible color payoff. It’s perfect for creating natural finishes or layering for a full glam look.
With a variety of shades, you can experiment with everything from soft neutral tones to bold, shimmery shades. Beauty editors swear by it, and for good reason—it’s worth every penny.
The That’s Taupe palette is one of my most-used palettes of all time. I absolutely love the cool toned neutrals in this palette, and the shimmers are out of this world! The Nude Mood palette is another great neutral option, the tones just lean a little more warm.
Milani Gilded Mini Eyeshadow Palette
The Milani Gilded Mini Eyeshadow Palette is small but mighty. These 6-pan palettes come in several different finishes and color stories, with options for matte finishes, shimmer finishes, or a mix of both.
The formula is pigmented and buttery, making it easy to blend and build for a polished eyeshadow look. This compact option is perfect for slipping into your bag for special occasions or for a quick and easy look.
I’ve really been enjoying the tones in the Call Me Old Fashioned palette!
Tips for Creating a Rock-Solid Eyeshadow Makeup Look
Achieving flawless eyeshadow looks is easier than you think when you start with the right preparation and techniques. Let’s dive deeper into each step so you can truly make the most of your drugstore eyeshadow palette and create looks that rival a makeup artist’s work.
Start with a Clean Base
Your lids need to be a clean, smooth canvas for your eyeshadow looks to pop. Oily lids or leftover makeup can cause shadows to crease or fade quickly. Use a swipe of micellar water to gently clean your lids.
If your skin is on the oilier side, pat them dry with a tissue to remove any excess moisture. A clean base ensures your eyeshadow primer or base color adheres perfectly.
Apply an Eyeshadow Primer
Skipping primer is a common mistake, but trust me, it’s a game-changer. An eyeshadow primer not only boosts the color payoff of your shadows but also helps them stay vibrant and crease-free for hours.
Priming doesn’t mean you have to use an eyeshadow primer.
If you don’t have a primer handy, a little concealer blended over your lids and set with a translucent powder can work just as well, if not even better. Priming ensures that you can layer shimmery shades or pops of colors without patchiness.
Use the Right Brushes
The tools you use are just as important as the shadows themselves. A fluffy brush is ideal for blending neutral tones in the crease or diffusing color on the lower lash line.
For precision, like packing a metallic shade onto the center of the lid or defining the outer corners, use a dense, flat brush. However, my personal favorite tool for shimmers is my finger. I feel like it packs the most punch!
A small, angled brush is perfect for adding a darker color along the lash line for extra dimension without looking as harsh as an eyeliner.
Don’t forget to keep your brushes clean—dirty brushes can muddle your colors and irritate sensitive skin.
Blend, Blend, Blend
Blending is the secret sauce to achieving a professional finish. When working with shadows you’re putting into the crease, always start with a light hand and gradually build the intensity. Use small, circular or windshield wiper motions to blend where two colors meet, creating a smooth transition.
A great trick is to use a clean brush to soften edges for that extra-polished eye look.
Layer for Dimension
Creating depth and dimension in your eyeshadow looks is all about layering. Start with a base color close to your skin tone to even out your lids.
Add a medium shade in the crease for definition, and deepen the outer corners with a darker shade.
Finally, add a touch of shimmery shade to the center of the lid or the inner corners to make your eyes pop. Playing with color theory—like pairing warm-toned shades with brown eyes—can elevate your look even more.
Set with Setting Spray
A spritz of setting spray can make all the difference, especially if you’re going for a bold or long-lasting wear look. Not only does it lock your shadows in place, but it can also intensify the pigment of shimmer finishes or metallic shades.
For a super vibrant finish, lightly mist your brush with setting spray before dipping it into your shadow.
Final Touches for a Flawless Look
For an extra polished look, don’t forget the bottom lash line! Smudge a darker shade along the lower lashes for a sultry vibe, or use a lighter shimmer to brighten the area. This looks extra defined without the harshness that eyeliner can give. Pair your eyeshadow looks with mascara or false lashes to define your eyes and tie everything together.
With these techniques, your drugstore eyeshadow palette can create everything from subtle daytime styles to dramatic evening glam.
When it comes to finding the best drugstore eyeshadow palette, these picks truly deliver on quality, versatility, and value. Whether you’re going for soft natural looks or bold eyeshadow looks, these palettes make it easy to create different looks for any occasion. The good thing? They’re affordable, accessible, and totally worth adding to your makeup collection.
Ready to level up your eye makeup game? Grab one of these palettes today and start experimenting with your new favorite eyeshadow looks!
