Updated November 8, 2019
Do you love high end concealers but are on a budget? Don’t you worry – I’ve found the best concealer dupes! I’ve found dupes for cult favorite concealers Shape Tape, Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer, Too Faced Born this Way Sculpting Concealer, Charlotte Tilbury Concealer, and It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye.
I’m so excited about this blog post and video – it’s been a long time coming! You all know I’m all about finding great dupes for our favorite high end products. When I was able to go through my collection and confidently find 5 drugstore concealers that were dupes to my favorite high end ones, I knew I had to do a whole post and video about it.
5 Drugstore Concealer Dupes for High End Favorites
Check out this video I made with a more in-depth analysis of these drugstore concealer dupes!
Hope you find the video helpful – especially the footage I have of me applying both the high end and drugstore concealers!
1. Nars Concealer Dupe
The Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer is a long time favorite concealer of mine, and has been well-loved for many years. It is full coverage with a satin finish. It looks beautiful under the eyes or on top of imperfections. I have talked about this Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer Dupe for many years, and have loved it so much! This Maybelline one is a little more dewy but has very similar coverage and feel. I really think you’ll love it!
2. Tarte Shape Tape Dupe
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer is one of those benchmark concealers everyone compares all others to. It was one of those concealers that really shook things up. It’s so full coverage and pretty darn crease-proof! The closest dupe I’ve been able to find to it is this dupe from e.l.f. It really is so similar, and I love the price point!
3. Too Faced Born This Way Sculpting Concealer Dupe
The Too Faced Born This Way Multi-Use Sculpting Concealer is my new holy grail concealer, especially for underneath the eyes. I find that Shape Tape can be too dry for me under my eyes (although it does have great coverage). This one is wonderful because it has a much more natural finish and sets beautifully. I recently tried this Cover Girl concealer and upon immediate application it reminded me of my beloved Too Faced. I have worn them side by side and they perform so similarly.
4. Charlotte Tilbury Concealer Dupe
The Charlotte Tilbury Magic Away concealer is a cult favorite among many. While I really do not like the packaging, I do love the consistency of the concealer. It’s gorgeous, medium soft-focus coverage, and a natural finish. But every time I use it, it reminds me so much of my Maybelline Instant Age Rewind concealer that I’ve loved for years and years. I think I actually like it better and will probably not repurchase the Charlotte Tilbury one.
5. It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Dupe
Bye Bye Under Eye is a lovely concealer that is super full coverage and covers literally everything – I don’t ever need to use a color corrector underneath! A little goes a loooong way. It’s very dewy and must be set with powder in order for it to stay in place, but it’s a wonderful concealer for mature skin and those that have very dry under eyes. This Maybelline concealer is a fabulous alternative. I will say that it’s not nearly as dewy (a little bit drier of a finish), but the coverage and pigment is very similar.
Did you love this drugstore concealer dupes blog post and video? Make sure you check out my other drugstore content, like…
The 5 Best Beauty Blender Dupes
Testing Popular High End Makeup Dupes
The Best Face Highlighter – Drugstore and High End
Drugstore Makeup Dupes Tested – A Full Face of High End vs. Drugstore
Hourglass Foundation Stick Dupe
…or browse all of my drugstore/dupes content HERE!